Are Character Traits Reliable?

Amanda Thomas Philosophy 103 November 19, 2012 Paper No. 2 In the book Experiments in Ethics by Kwame Anthony Appiah he states that individualistic moments of compassion and honesty makes our lives better, even if we are not compassionate through with(predicate) and through. (Appiah 70) He also continues on to say that we backt be content with knowing what change of passel we are it matters, too, what kind of commonwealth we hope to be (Appiah 72). He discusses the relationship between object lesson philosophy andscientific research.He used some research experiments such as Milgrams and The impregnable Samaritan to further explain this quote. During these discussions he explains the difference between situationist and globalist/ fairness ethics. Situationists are people who feel that what predicts behaviour are situational factors instead of grapheme traits. Globalists disagree with that statement and argue that contribution traits predict style. They also send word that good actions are defined as those done by people with the proper sexual abstentions and that virtues exist as part of individuals graphic symbol makeup.A variety of mental studies doubt these expound. The main issue is whether we have stable personality and character traits. Appiah uses modus tollens to give a logic every(prenominal)y from of the situationist argument. If the succus is made with sugar, thence the juice is sweet. The juice is not sweet. Therefore, the juice is not made with sugar. One premises using modus tollens that a situationist could agree on is that if virtue ethics is true, then character traits predict behavior. Character traits dont predict behavior therefore virtue ethics is not true.Appiah takes the Milgram experiment to rule out(p) real strong forms of virtue ethics. He notes that virtue ethics can still come as a guide to life, defining the ideals that should serve as our aims, even thought we rarely live up to them. honourable psychology impose s limits on the kind of people we can become. Appiah uses a sound out that is, of course, necessary to consider in combination with the quote just mentioned, which is this We flawed creatures (Appiah 53). Darley and Batsons Good Samaritan study was conducted by viewing helping behavior in which students at the PrincetonTheological Seminary were asked to make individual presentations on the story of The Good Samaritan. The partner in crime was slumped in a doorway in need of help. Unrushed seminarians helped the accomplice over 60% of the time. When seminarians were told beforehand that they were late for their presentation the helping account dropped dramatically. Appiah accepts that if the situationist case is as right, then globalism needs to be rejected. However, he argues that virtue ethics can live on even with the end of globalism, or at least he argues that virtue still matters in a world in which situationist lessons are learned.We hope to develop consistent character t raits and to withstand a highly assimilated character, the efforts of attempting to behave in ways found that virtues is one that is worth making. It makes our lives better if we help others a bit more(prenominal) when we are in a hurry than we would if we were unconcerned about attempting to obtain the virtues. He also feels that one can take and embrace the impartiality in both virtue ethics and situationist by putting people in situations where their virtue is maximized. He feels that the premises arent necessarily all true.Appiah believes that experimental research has an even deeper connection to morality. To some extent, we have to corporate trust our gut feelings when determining what is right and wrong. He states in Chapter 1 that The adjunction of virtue ethics and situationism urges us to make it easier both to avoid doing what murderers do and to avoid being what murderersare. I believe that Appiahs view on virtue ethics and situationist is true. Character traits are nt completely reliable and certain character traits can help determine how you act in a certain situation but, also certain situations can completely let down your character traits.